Hello folks. Beliefs and high expectations for a stock can affect the valuation of a stock. A good example is
$PLTR because of my belief in a bright future for AI software platforms and for the business model of Palantir. The parameters of my narrative are the following:
- The total value of the AI software platform at 570 Billion in 2033.
- Palantir market share at 6%.
- Operating margins at 30%.
- Sales to capital at 1.50 (The average in the software sector is 0.90).
I found a value per share at 19$ and I thought " Ok, Palantir is undervalued by 30% and I accept the price that the market offers me".
Before closing my valuation spreadsheet I looked again at my valuation and specifically the parameters on Terminal year (the value for perpetuity) which was:
- Revenues growth = 10y US Bond (No company can grow faster than the economy)
- Operating margin = 30% (It's ok because has an established business model with lower prices)
- Reinvestment Rate = 1.5 (Experinece leads the way in efficiency)
- ROIC = 22% !!!!!!!
When I attached the value of 22% in ROIC perpetuity it was like to assume that Palantir will have a competitive advantage forever which is a HUGE assumption in valuation. To illustrate an example, I have assumed that Palantir will be like Coca-Cola but in the Software sector, or Walmart in the retailing sector. When I changed ROIC to 8%, which is the average for most global companies, my valuation suddenly droped at 13$ per share.
Closing Thoughts
Beliefs are one of the worst enemies in valuation because we are starting to have subjective views for a stock. Furthermore, my example comes in contrast with the theory of the circle of competence that has been proposed by Warrent Buffett because the more you investigate a stock, more likely is to gain a subjective view that will affect negative the results.
If someone belives that Palantir will keep his competitive advantage for perpetuity then the market price is a good offer for him. On the other hand, if someone believes that Palnatir will become a typical global company then company has reached for good the overvalued levels.
Below it is my newsletter on
$PLTR. Thank you!