Trending Assets
Top investors this month
Trending Assets
Top investors this month
Is Jack Dorsey a true believer in financial fairness for all?
We revisited Block $SQ this week on our podcast, and I was once again blown away by the unit economics at their two core businesses -- Square and the Cash App. For example, at the Cash App, it costs $10 on average to acquire an active customer and within 3 years each of those customers contributes $60 in gross profit. Impressive.

The unfortunate part however, is that none of the dollars generated by these wonderful businesses actually go to the shareholders. Instead it goes to things like buying Afterpay at a clear premium, buying Tidal so Jack can be friends with Jay-Z, and random bitcoin projects because Jack says so (and just overall operating expenses). I know I sound like a hater, but bear with me.

There are probably some people that believe in not only what Jack Dorsey says about how bitcoin can level the playing field for everyone and democratize the financial system and so on, but also probably believe in him as a CEO. I respect that. What I dislike though, is the hypocrisy of it all.

In last year's proxy statement, there was a proposal to gradually remove the disproportionate voting rights on the dual class share structure. If this happened, that would mean that every share would be equal to one vote, aka fairness for all, right? However, the board (led by Dorsey) opposed the deal. Now why would some who is so in favor of leveling the playing vote against something that does just that? Well because he'd lose his voting power. So he's a fan of fairness for all but only when it benefits him.

If the share structure was changed, it would allow activists to step in and help realize what the business is truly worth. If that ever happens, I will be once again eager to be a shareholder, but until it does I have a hard time owning the business given that there is literally no telling what Jack Dorsey will do with the money. Maybe he'll buy another $500 million worth of bitcoin or even more, who knows?

We broke down the whole business here for those that want to listen: https://open.spotify.com/episode/1MXPZhLJE3SxpB1NdhbTfU?si=b3aLEENsRxev8k4J66zzZg
Spotify
Block (Ticker: SQ) Not So Deep Dive
Chit Chat Stocks · Episode

Alan's avatar
Tidal and Bitcoin projects cost very little as a proportion of overall costs.

On the face of it, they used too much of their own stock to acquire Afterpay (though both Square and Afterpay were very richly valued at the time). However, the Discover Tab could be hugely profitable so I think we have to reserve judgement on the Afterpay purchase for now.


Related
Already have an account?