$DGX still attractive
Comparing $DGX (a company I can’t find a reason NOT to buy) and it’s peers today, came across $LH. This is how I find a lot of great companies, the peer comparison tab on Seeking Alpha. I’ve never come across companies so statistically equal on so many growth/profit/valuation metrics. Quest pays a dividend though, still one of my favorites in the sector and overall. A P/E around 9 & EV/EBITDA around 7 is absurd. So, Quest is still looking like a buy to me.

Any opinions on Quest Diagnostics? It seems like one of those common sense buys that’s easy pickings (where the little Warren Buffet on my shoulder is screaming at me to buy something). Looks like a well established, profitable company selling at very attractive valuations. I’m okay with stability, don’t require growth as much as most. With $10 billion in revenues I’m okay with stability and industry position over growth, that’s just kind of my basic philosophy. More of an established value weighted, over growth weighted, investor.
Invitae - Cost Declines of Sequencing A Human Genome Will Surprise
In 2003 the Human Genome project finished sequencing the first human genome at a cost of $2.7 billion dollars. Today, it costs less than $1,000:

As prices continue to drop, being able to sequence the entire population's genome has become a possibility. This would be a watershed moment in health care, enabling early detection and diagnosis of diseases such as cancer, which would lead to significantly increased survival rates, new cures, treatments, and huge healthcare cost savings.

As of today however, costs are still prohibitive. While you can get a 23andMe test for $199, it tests for only three variants in two genes (BRCA1 and BRCA2), which is woefully inadequate, because there are more than 1,000 variants in these genes that can elevate individuals’ cancer risks.

In other words, a report from 23andMe showing that you don’t have a BRCA mutation doesn’t necessarily mean you’re in the clear.

This highlights the need for experts to be part of the process, as getting a more complete test generates orders of magnitude more data, which requires a clinician to interpret and advise on action steps.

For genomics testing to reach its full potential, it needs to be integrated with the healthcare system; the business model will need to include doctors, not be entirely self-serve.

But integrating genomics tests into the healthcare system is hard; insurance coverage is limited, clinics that offer genetic testing are few and far between, and interpreting the data from these tests isn't easy.

Invitae is focused on building a solution to address these remaining concerns. And they are so excited about the global genetic testing market, they offer competitive pricing to 23andMe, but with the service 23andMe lacks. Invitae offers a "clinical-grade" cancer test for only $250 in which an independent physician reviews your health history in order to put the test results in context.

Offering this much quality at this low of a price this early in the genetics game is not a sustainable business model. For this to work, two big things need to happen:

1) The cost of sequencing a human genome needs to continue to fall
2) The usefulness of genomic information in diagnosing and treating diseases such as cancer needs to continue to materialize.

Other competitors in the space (Quest Diagnostics $DGX , LabCorp $LH, Blueprint Genetics, OPKO Health $OPK , Myriad Genetics $MYGN , Natera $NTRA and NeoGenomics ) are all betting that sequencing costs will fall more linearly.

Invitae is going out on a limb by predicting that sequencing costs will fall in-step with Wright's Law, rather than Moore's Law.

Wright's Law states that for every cumulative doubling of units produced, costs will fall by a constant percentage. Read: cost declines will look more exponential rather than linear.

What this means is that there is a chicken and egg problem: demand needs to be high enough to reach the scale necessary for prices to be low enough to stimulate demand.

Invitae is boldly stepping up to the plate to take on the risk of dropping prices to "unsustainable levels", because they are betting they can crack the egg-chicken problem. I mean chicken and egg problem. You get what I mean. They think they can make the market before going bankrupt. Game on.

If they crack the code first, it will likely be a winner-take-most market, because only Invitae will have the scale necessary to keep the prices low, and it will be even harder for any challengers to follow because Invitae will already be servicing a majority of the market.

And the fun doesn't stop there. Once you have one player cracking the scale problem, they are essentially sitting on a huge oil deposit of genetic health data, which can be anonymized and converted into a machine learning goldmine.

The likelihood of wishlist items like "a cure for cancer" goes up when we have the data sets necessary to train machine learning algorithms to make connections to our health that normal humans could never make.

The global genetic testing market is expected to grow at a double-digit rate and reach $16.9 billion by 2025. Personally I think it could be much bigger than that, although, I also don't think the full potential of this space will be reached within 5 years. I bought more Invitae shares $NVTA yesterday and I am long for at least the next decade.

The way I see it, Invitae will either hit it big, or the business modal won't work and they'll go out of business. This is not something to put your whole portfolio behind. But personally I made the decision to start a position and will be adding more as I continue to follow the space.

Please put any thoughts or questions in the comments. I would love to follow this company with a community of people. Changing the world doesn't have to be lonely.

Nathan
post media
Thanks for writing this. I own $NVTA but have my reservations. It kind of rubs me the wrong way that they've priced their tests as though they've achieved the operational efficiencies that would have warranted the lower costs. Seems like they've chosen to go on a suicide mission that some other company might be the beneficiary of years from now.
View 13 more comments
Invitae - Risks
I've started to notice that people are buying some companies when I talk about them, so I want to adjust my approach.

I am going to start my discussion of a company with the risks- And first set an initial goal of completely scaring you out of wanting to invest. With that as the starting place, I will then give my bull case.

Signal over noise starts with understanding the downside.

For Invitae the bear case is that they have increasingly negative net income:

By the way I'm using a great tool created by @investmenttalk which reminds me of the spreadsheets I would fill out while doing my MBA. It's a really good educational practice to go through 10ks and fill out spreadsheets like this. It's a manual process, but it gives you time to slow down and think. You can check out @investmenttalk's 'Analyst Took Kit' on gumroad.

Anyway, Invitae is essentially incinerating cash in order to be the low cost provider of genomic testing. There's a reason why competitors like Quest Diagnostics $DGX are reluctant to drop prices in step, because if they did, they would be losing money like Invitae is.

Additionally, Invitae's business model is heavily dependent on medicare reimbursement. If the Center for Medicare Services (CMS) decides to exclude coverage for next generation sequencing tests for patients with earlier stage cancers, that would be very bad for Invitae.

In Q2 of 2019, Invitae disclosed that Medicare made up 22% of revenue for the first six months of that year.

At the moment, there is a very real possibility that Invitae can't get their business model to work without constantly requiring cash injections from investors.

Right now leinent and hopeful investors are the only thing giving Invitae the runway to keep trying to figure out the business model, which requires both that genomic sequencing costs continue to drop precipitously and that the demand for the tests will rise like crazy. While this could happen, it by no means is where the world is going for sure.
post mediapost media
Next
Commonstock is a social network that amplifies the knowledge of the best investors, verified by actual track records for signal over noise. Community members can link their existing brokerage accounts and share their real time portfolio, performance and trades (by percent only, dollar amounts never shared). Commonstock is not a brokerage, but a social layer on top of existing brokerages helping to create more engaged and informed investors.